3 /5 Beni Hudak: Food - Mediocre is the most accurately I could describe what Ive had. As much as its mostly a seafood place and I do not eat seafood (it was not my choice to come here), what I did have, the taste-o-rama, certainly was ok. The coleslaw, its coleslaw alright!; the beans, ok, but regular baked beans wouldve been better; the chicken and pork rib both were quite bland and not very BBQ, despite advertisement; the cornbread, is cool I guess but the meat sauces ruin the bottom & the pulled pork was actually pretty solid, I wont deny that. Best part was certainly the milkshake though, though Id be surprised if you messed that up. It certainly set good first impressions though, unfortunately not maintained.
Service - It was fine. Not the friendliest but not bad. That said, despite it being not very busy, I was given the wrong persons meal, and when they took it back, it took another 8 minutes to get mine and my brothers meals. Ouch. They were apologetic though, and not overly, so it was handled well after. Other than that, fine, although they did come to ask for orders a bit too soon.
Atmosphere - Hey, pretty good! Facing out into the rest of Bluewater certainly isnt ideal for atmosphere, but it was fairly solid. They had 2 musicians, a pianist/singer, and a drummer, who were quite good. Outside that, the music playing before and after was, good, but thats up to personal preference. The aesthetics were also neat, again, nothing mind-blowing but good.
To sum it up, I, truthfully, wouldnt say this is my first recommendation for American (especially not after the glorious new Smokehouse we vistwdast month, certainly a tough act to follow). Its not awful though, and again, I feel this is very important to say, I did NOT try the seafood AT the seafood place, so do take this with a grain of salt.